Sunday, December 11, 2011

Lindsay Lohan: Validly, A Non Strong Minded Individual

P1:  Some people identicle to Lindsay Lohan are people who are bulimic.
P2:  All people who are bulimic are non strong minded individuals.

C:  Therefore, some non strong minded individuals are people who are identicle to Lindsay Lohan.


Would be set up as:
P1:  Some p are b.
P2:  All b are n.
C:  Some n are p.



Diagramming the universal "All b are n." first would be:



Then the particular "Some p are b":


This proves this IAI - 4 syllogism valid because the conclusion "Some n are p" is diagrammed as follows:

1 comment:

  1. I think you have correctly diagrammed your argument. I diagrammed it out myself to see if I would get the same answer and I did. Hopefully we are both correct!

    ReplyDelete